Insights

How the UK’s New Settlement Rules Compare to Europe and North America

The UK’s default wait for indefinite leave to remain will double from 5 to 10 years. How does the new system compare with Europe, the US and Canada?

Last week’s Budget promised to deliver “the most pro-business migration system in Europe for high-skill workers” for the UK, while continuing to tighten the rules for low- and medium-skilled workers.

On Monday, the Home Secretary repeated the pro-business pledge when setting out the final decision on the Earned Settlement scheme, with changes to be laid in the Immigration Rules from December 2026 and implemented through 2027.

Taken together, the announcements make one thing clear: the UK is rewarding high earners and certain public service professions, while making settlement a slower journey for everyone else. As we now know, the default wait for indefinite leave to remain (ILR) will double from 5 to 10 years.

The time it takes to settle matters, because the decision to migrate is often informed by it, and it is what makes a move worthwhile. Relocating abroad for work comes with the prospect of putting down permanent roots, sometimes as a family, and the cost and uncertainty of repeated visa renewals often deter people from making the decision in the first place.

This article does not repeat the rules but asks the question: if the UK is competing for talent, how does the new system compare with Europe, and with its main English-speaking rivals, the US and Canada?

The new UK settlement tiers

Under the new model, the time to settlement depends on what you earn and what you do:

Qualifying periodWho it applies to
3 yearsAt least £125,141 a year and the highest-skilled routes, such as Global Talent and Innovator Founder
5 yearsAt least £50,271 a year and some public service workers
10 yearsThe new default for everyone else
20 years or moreThose who have breached immigration rules

Every applicant must also meet four baseline conditions: a clean criminal record, English to a high standard (equivalent to A-Level English as a foreign language), no debt owed to the taxpayer, and a record of sustained National Insurance contributions.

Top and higher earners: competitive, but not ahead

For workers earning above £50,271, the UK’s 5-year route stays where it is today. The UK attaches a much higher salary condition to it, but gives the UK no edge over Europe. For higher earners, the UK makes a strong case. For top earners on at least £125,141, the 3-year route beats the 5-year wait in the Netherlands, France and Spain, and comes close to Germany’s Blue Card without the German test or the long processing queues.

Germany is a top rival competing for skilled talent. EU Blue Card holders earning at least €50,700 (€45,934.20 in shortage occupations) can settle after 27 months of employment with basic German (A1), or 21 months with B1 German. While this appears to be faster on paper, waits for visa appointments can range from a few weeks to several months depending on location. Settlement applications can also take a long time: in Munich, for example, processing can take up to 12 months.

The Netherlands grants permanent residence after 5 consecutive years, with an income threshold set at the minimum wage and an A2 civic integration exam. Salary matters at the start instead: the main skilled route requires €5,942 gross a month from age 30, or €4,357 under 30, in 2026. Earning more does not shorten the 5 years.

France also sets a 5-year path, with a low income bar (at least the minimum wage, €1,867.02 gross a month) but a higher language bar than its neighbours: B1 French and a civic exam.

Spain follows the same 5-year line, with no language or integration test for permanent residence. Since June 2026, its EU Blue Card has required €41,356.36 gross a year, or €33,085.09 for shortage occupations and recent graduates, but holding one does not shorten the wait.

One advantage the UK cannot offer: an EU Blue Card holder who moves between EU countries can add together time spent in each towards EU long-term residence, provided the last two years are on a Blue Card in the country where they apply. A career that moves between, say, Germany and Spain does not restart the clock.

North America: a different model

Canada has a different system. Express Entry is a direct pathway to permanent residence for the selected skilled worker, with differences in requirements in the specific routes. The hurdle is the selection process, where candidates are ranked by points and applications are by invitation only. The process then takes around six to seven months. With Canada also cutting temporary worker arrivals in 2026, the in-country route to settlement is narrowing.

The US has a similar structure on paper. Employment-based immigrant categories provide a direct route to lawful permanent residence (a green card) principally through EB-2 for professionals holding advanced degrees or individuals with exceptional ability (including a self-petition route through the National Interest Waiver), and EB-3 for skilled workers and professionals, generally requiring an employer-sponsored job offer. In practice, a significant proportion of employment-based green cards go to people already in the US and green cards are subject to annual caps and a 7% per-country limit, which means long waits for applicants from certain countries.

Pro-business, but for whom?

The difference is where each country puts its filter. Canada and the US select at the outset; the UK now filters at settlement. For top earners, the UK’s 3-year route keeps it in rivalry with Germany’s Blue Card. For the majority of skilled workers, the UK now asks for twice as long as Europe. For anyone weighing a move, route choice and salary now decide how long it takes to put down roots.

How Caretta Global can help

Choosing the right country and route matters more than ever. Caretta Global guides individuals and companies through these choices across Europe and North America, helping them find the destination and route that best suit their specific needs. Whether you are planning your own move or relocating talent for your business, we can help you compare the options and plan a clear path to settlement.

This article is general information, not legal advice. The new rules will be laid from December 2026 and details may change.